A Comprehensive Retrospective: or How We Learned to Stop Worrying and Release Bad and Useless Recordings cover

A Comprehensive Retrospective: or How We Learned to Stop Worrying and Release Bad and Useless Recordings

Shai Hulud · 2005

65 min · 24 tracks · progressive metal

A chaotic blend of progressive metal and hardcore, infused with raw energy and introspective lyrics that challenge societal norms.

Top tracks — play these first

  • →
    This Wake I Myself Have Stirred — This track encapsulates Shai Hulud's signature sound with its intricate melodies and powerful lyrical themes, serving as both a fan favorite and a showcase of their musical evolution.
  • →
    Unlearned — The song's concise structure and aggressive delivery highlight the band's ability to balance complexity with accessibility, making it a hallmark of their early work.
  • →
    Hardly — As one of the standout tracks from their discography, 'Hardly' combines intense instrumentation with thought-provoking lyrics, representing the emotional depth typical of Shai Hulud's music.

Is this for you?

Good fit if you like

  • restless bursts across alternate takes
  • raw live-room unpredictability
  • scrappy demos beside finished songs
  • a 24-track archival deep dive

Maybe skip if you

  • want a tightly curated sequence
  • prefer consistent versions and polish

Where this album fits

In the catalog
Deep Cut — A compilation of rarities and archival material, offering context on the band's catalog rather than serving as a main...
Career context
Released on January 25, 2005, this compilation album came after Shai Hulud's previous studio album, 'That Within Blood Ill-Tempered' (2003), showcasing a transitional phase in their career. The band was solidifying their legacy in the metalcore scene while experimenting with ideas and recordings that had previously been unreleased or reimagined.

Moments worth listening for

Where the writing does something specific.

  • This Wake I Myself Have Stirred

    In the bridge, the narrative shifts from an external critique to a personal confession of self-doubt and reflection on one's choices.

Tracklist

Best experienced from track one — press play and let it unfold.

  • 1 Hardly 3:11
  • 2 Orwell 2:13
  • 3 Unlearned 2:08
  • 4 Sauve qui peut 2:38
  • 5 This Wake I Myself Have Stirred 2:45
  • 6 Favor 3:04
  • 7 Solely Concentrating on the Negative Aspects of Life (live) 4:07
  • 8 Gyroscope (live) 1:53
  • 9 Hardly (live) 4:14
  • 10 “Stop Now!” 0:07
  • 11 Keep Your Day Jobs 0:52
  • 12 New Song (Sauve qui peut) 3:07
  • 13 Tree (Hardly) 3:16
  • 14 This Wake I Myself Have Stirred 2:44
  • 15 Unlearned 2:11
  • 16 This Wake I Myself Have Stirred 3:01
  • 17 For the World 3:02
  • 18 This Wake I Myself Have Stirred 2:54
  • 19 Hardly 3:28
  • 20 Unlearned (scratch track) 2:16
  • 21 100 Acre Wood (scratch track) 3:52
  • 22 Tree (Hardly) (scratch track) 3:06
  • 23 This Wake I Myself Have Stirred (scratch track) 2:49
  • 24 Sauve qui peut (For the World) (scratch track) 2:41

Reference: Wikipedia · MusicBrainz · Wikidata