A Comprehensive Retrospective: or How We Learned to Stop Worrying and Release Bad and Useless Recordings
Shai Hulud · 2005
65 min · 24 tracks · progressive metal
A chaotic blend of progressive metal and hardcore, infused with raw energy and introspective lyrics that challenge societal norms.
Top tracks — play these first
-
→
This Wake I Myself Have Stirred — This track encapsulates Shai Hulud's signature sound with its intricate melodies and powerful lyrical themes, serving as both a fan favorite and a showcase of their musical evolution.
-
→
Unlearned — The song's concise structure and aggressive delivery highlight the band's ability to balance complexity with accessibility, making it a hallmark of their early work.
-
→
Hardly — As one of the standout tracks from their discography, 'Hardly' combines intense instrumentation with thought-provoking lyrics, representing the emotional depth typical of Shai Hulud's music.
Is this for you?
Good fit if you like
- restless bursts across alternate takes
- raw live-room unpredictability
- scrappy demos beside finished songs
- a 24-track archival deep dive
Maybe skip if you
- want a tightly curated sequence
- prefer consistent versions and polish
Where this album fits
- In the catalog
- Deep Cut — A compilation of rarities and archival material, offering context on the band's catalog rather than serving as a main...
- Career context
- Released on January 25, 2005, this compilation album came after Shai Hulud's previous studio album, 'That Within Blood Ill-Tempered' (2003), showcasing a transitional phase in their career. The band was solidifying their legacy in the metalcore scene while experimenting with ideas and recordings that had previously been unreleased or reimagined.
- Stylistic neighbors
- The Contortionist· Between the Buried and Me· August Burns Red
Moments worth listening for
Where the writing does something specific.
-
This Wake I Myself Have Stirred
In the bridge, the narrative shifts from an external critique to a personal confession of self-doubt and reflection on one's choices.
Tracklist
Best experienced from track one — press play and let it unfold.
- 1 Hardly 3:11
- 2 Orwell 2:13
- 3 Unlearned 2:08
- 4 Sauve qui peut 2:38
- 5 This Wake I Myself Have Stirred 2:45
- 6 Favor 3:04
- 7 Solely Concentrating on the Negative Aspects of Life (live) 4:07
- 8 Gyroscope (live) 1:53
- 9 Hardly (live) 4:14
- 10 “Stop Now!” 0:07
- 11 Keep Your Day Jobs 0:52
- 12 New Song (Sauve qui peut) 3:07
- 13 Tree (Hardly) 3:16
- 14 This Wake I Myself Have Stirred 2:44
- 15 Unlearned 2:11
- 16 This Wake I Myself Have Stirred 3:01
- 17 For the World 3:02
- 18 This Wake I Myself Have Stirred 2:54
- 19 Hardly 3:28
- 20 Unlearned (scratch track) 2:16
- 21 100 Acre Wood (scratch track) 3:52
- 22 Tree (Hardly) (scratch track) 3:06
- 23 This Wake I Myself Have Stirred (scratch track) 2:49
- 24 Sauve qui peut (For the World) (scratch track) 2:41
Reference: Wikipedia · MusicBrainz · Wikidata
Sync your library
Everything you track here works immediately — no account needed. Create one when you want to sync across devices.