Weihnachtsoratorium BWV 248 cover

Weihnachtsoratorium BWV 248

Peter Schreier · 2007

150 min · 65 tracks · opera

Elevation

Our rating, out of 100 — and why.

AI-generated from five scored dimensions. An opinion, not a measurement.

89 /100
Summit
Higher than 83% of opera albums we've rated
Higher than 99% of albums we've rated

The recurring shifts between narration, aria and chorale give the six-part work a strong dramatic shape; this recording serves that structure with assured execution.

What we noticed

  • The six-part structure repeatedly alternates Evangelist recitatives with arias and chorales, so narrative narration gives way to reflective pauses rather than running continuously.
  • Each cantata has its own opening and closing frame; the pastoral Sinfonia in Part II interrupts the vocal sequence with an instrumental scene.
  • The 65-track listing follows the work’s numbered movements, making short recitatives and chorales frequent transitions between longer arias and choruses.
Composition 25% of the score
9/10

the writing — melody, harmony, structure, lyrics

Craft 20% of the score
8/10

production, performance, arrangement

Durability 25% of the score
9/10

whether it rewards returning to it

Distinctiveness 18% of the score
6/10

whether it sounds like itself

Sequencing 12% of the score
8/10

running order, pacing, length

Influence 3/10

Known within its scene. Reported but not counted — how far a record travelled describes its reception rather than the record, and a newer release has had less time to travel than an older one.

Tracklist

Best experienced from track one — press play and let it unfold.

Disc 1

  • 1 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 1 Chor 7:37
  • 2 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 2 Rezitativ – Evangelist (Tenor) 1:23
  • 3 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 3 Rezitativ – Alt 1:02
  • 4 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 4 Arie – Alt 5:31
  • 5 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 5 Choral 1:17
  • 6 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 6 Rezitativ – Evangelist
  • 7 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 7 Choral und Rezitativ – Chorsopran und Bass 3:37
  • 8 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 8 Arie – Bass 4:42
  • 9 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 9 Choral 1:15
  • 10 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 10 Sinfonia (Hirtenmusik) 6:25
  • 11 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 11 Rezitativ – Evangelist 0:51
  • 12 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 12 Choral 1:08
  • 13 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 13 Rezitativ – Evangelist / Der Engel (Sopran) 0:50
  • 14 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 14 Rezitativ – Bass 0:38
  • 15 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 15 Arie – Tenor 3:35
  • 16 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 16 Rezitativ – Der Engel 0:23
  • 17 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 17 Choral 0:38
  • 18 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 18 Rezitativ – Bass 0:59
  • 19 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 19 Arie – Alt 9:01
  • 20 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 20 Rezitativ – Evangelist 0:16
  • 21 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 21 Chor 2:46
  • 22 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 22 Rezitativ – Bass 0:22
  • 23 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 23 Choral 1:20

Disc 2

  • 1 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 24 Chor 1:49
  • 2 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 25 Rezitativ – Evangelist
  • 3 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 26 Chor
  • 4 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 27 Rezitativ – Bass 1:40
  • 5 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 28 Choral 0:47
  • 6 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 29 Duett – Sopran und Bass 8:17
  • 7 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 30 Rezitativ – Evangelist 1:23
  • 8 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 31 Arie – Alt 5:40
  • 9 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 32 Rezitativ – Alt 0:28
  • 10 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 33 Choral 0:57
  • 11 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 34 Rezitativ – Evangelist 0:22
  • 12 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 35 Choral 0:54
  • 13 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Wiederholung von Chor Nr. 24 1:47
  • 14 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 36 Chor 5:26
  • 15 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 37 Rezitativ – Evangelist 0:34
  • 16 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 38 Rezitativ und Choral – Bass / Sopran und Bass / Bass 2:50
  • 17 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 39 Arie – Sopran und Echo‐Sopran 5:37
  • 18 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 40 Rezitativ mit Choral – Rezitativ (Bass) / Arioso (Sopran) 1:37
  • 19 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 41 Arie – Tenor 4:59
  • 20 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 42 Choral 2:01

Disc 3

  • 1 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 43 Chor 6:55
  • 2 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 44 Rezitativ – Evangelist
  • 3 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 45 Chor und Rezitativ – Chor und Alt 2:26
  • 4 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 46 Choral 0:51
  • 5 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 47 Arie – Bass 4:45
  • 6 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 48 Rezitativ – Evangelist
  • 7 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 49 Rezitativ – Alt 0:47
  • 8 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 50 Rezitativ – Evangelist 1:19
  • 9 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 51 Terzett – Sopran / Tenor / Alt / Sopran und Tenor 5:49
  • 10 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 52 Rezitativ – Alt 0:29
  • 11 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 53 Choral 0:52
  • 12 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 54 Chor 4:55
  • 13 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 55 Rezitativ – Evangelist / Herodes (Bass) 0:54
  • 14 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 56 Rezitativ – Sopran 0:50
  • 15 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 57 Arie – Sopran 3:31
  • 16 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 58 Rezitativ – Evangelist 1:13
  • 17 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 59 Choral 1:03
  • 18 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 60 Rezitativ – Evangelist 0:23
  • 19 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 61 Rezitativ – Tenor 1:53
  • 20 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 62 Arie – Tenor 4:33
  • 21 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 63 Rezitativ – Sopran, Alt, Tenor, Bass 0:45
  • 22 Weihnachts‐Oratorium BWV 248: Nr. 64 Choral 3:11

Reference: MusicBrainz