Manchester Orchestra albums, ranked

12 records, ordered by our Elevation score — our rating out of 100, not chart position.

Start here

A Black Mile to the Surface

A Black Mile to the Surface

2017

Offers a cohesive experience that showcases layered dynamics and emotional depth, representing their signature sound effectively.

  1. 1
    A Black Mile to the Surface

    A Black Mile to the Surface Start here

    2017

    A haunting exploration of personal and collective grief woven through atmospheric indie rock landscapes.

  2. 2
    The Million Masks of God

    The Million Masks of God

    2021

    A sweeping exploration of grief and redemption wrapped in atmospheric indie rock textures and poignant lyricism.

  3. 3
    Mean Everything to Nothing

    Mean Everything to Nothing

    2009

    A raw and dynamic exploration of emotional turbulence wrapped in anthemic indie rock melodies.

  4. 4
    Simple Math

    Simple Math

    2011

    A haunting exploration of emotional turmoil wrapped in expansive indie rock arrangements and poignant lyricism.

  5. 5
    Cope

    Cope

    2014

    A visceral blend of soaring melodies and raw, confessional lyrics wrapped in dynamic indie rock instrumentation.

  6. 6
    The Valley of Vision

    The Valley of Vision

    2023

    A reflective journey through sorrow and hope, wrapped in atmospheric indie rock textures and poignant lyrical depth.

  7. 7
    You Brainstorm, I Brainstorm, but Brilliance Needs a Good Editor

    You Brainstorm, I Brainstorm, but Brilliance Needs a Good Editor

    2005

    Raw and introspective melodies intertwine with sharp lyrical observations, creating a soundscape rich in emotional complexity.

  8. 8
    I'm Like a Virgin Losing a Child

    I'm Like a Virgin Losing a Child

    2006

    A raw, emotionally charged exploration of loss and introspection wrapped in intricate melodies and soaring instrumentation.

  9. 9
    I Could Be the Only One

    I Could Be the Only One

    2010

    A contemplative blend of soaring melodies and introspective lyrics that encapsulate the emotional weight of human connection.

  10. 10
    Hope

    Hope

    2014

    A haunting blend of introspective lyrics and expansive soundscapes that capture the complexity of hope and despair.

  11. 11
    5 Stories

    5 Stories

    2004

    Haunting melodies intertwine with introspective lyrics, creating a rich tapestry of emotional landscapes within the indie rock genre.

  12. 12
    Let My Pride Be What's Left Behind

    Let My Pride Be What's Left Behind

    2008

    An introspective blend of raw emotion and atmospheric instrumentation that captures the essence of loss and longing.