Maine albums, ranked

12 records, ordered by our Elevation score — our rating out of 100, not chart position.

Start here

Lovely Little Lonely

Lovely Little Lonely

2017

Captures their signature sound with emotional depth and melodic richness, making it accessible for new listeners.

  1. 1
    Imaginary Numbers

    Imaginary Numbers

    2013

    Acoustic guitars and spare arrangements draw The Maine’s alternative rock inward, giving John O’Callaghan’s voice room to linger.

  2. 2
    American Candy

    American Candy

    2015

    Sunlit guitar hooks and buoyant rhythms give way to moments of anxiety beneath the album’s bright surface.

  3. 3
    XOXO: From Love and Anxiety in Real Time

    XOXO: From Love and Anxiety in Real Time

    2021

    Bright pop-rock choruses and polished guitars give way to quieter passages where anxiety interrupts the rush of romance.

  4. 4
    Black & White

    Black & White

    2010

    Polished pop-rock choruses meet warmer guitars as The Maine stretch their youthful urgency toward a more open-road sound.

  5. 5
    Lovely Little Lonely

    Lovely Little Lonely Start here

    2017

    Bright alternative rock hooks sweep through dreamy transitions while John O’Callaghan’s voice gives the album’s nostalgia an unsettled edge.

  6. 6
    Forever Halloween

    Forever Halloween

    2013

    Analog tape lends these bruised rock songs a live-room immediacy that makes their quieter confessions feel close enough to overhear.

  7. 7
    The Maine

    The Maine

    2023

    Polished alternative rock turns restless thoughts into bright hooks, with electronic textures flickering around the guitars.

  8. 8
    Pioneer

    Pioneer

    2012

    Guitar-driven alternative rock trades pop-punk polish for a dustier sound, with John O’Callaghan’s voice pushing between intimacy and open-road release.

  9. 9
    ...And a Happy New Year

    ...And a Happy New Year

    2008

    Holiday pop-punk turns Christmas cheer into a stage for romantic longing and mischief.

  10. 10
    Stay Up, Get Down EP

    Stay Up, Get Down EP

    2007

    Bright guitars and urgent pop-punk hooks give teenage restlessness a dance-floor pulse.

  11. 11
    Can't Stop, Won't Stop

    Can't Stop, Won't Stop

    2008

    Energetic guitar riffs and anthemic choruses capture a youthful exuberance, reflecting the band's optimism and determination.

  12. 12
    The Way We Talk EP

    The Way We Talk EP

    2007

    Bright guitar hooks and brisk pop-punk rhythms give these songs the restless energy of conversations moving too fast to finish.