Where to start with hip-hop

A five-album path through hip-hop, taken chronologically — because each of these records was built from the one before it, and hearing them in order is hearing the form invent itself.

genre_entry
Hip-hop is the hardest genre to enter sideways, because almost every record is in conversation with the records around it. Start in the middle and you get the references without the argument. So this goes in order, 1988 to 2004: sixteen years in which the music moves from noise collage to something closer to composition, and every step is audible. Four of these were made before sample clearance made their methods illegal, which is part of why nothing sounds like them now.

5 steps

1
It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back
1. The noise It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back Public Enemy · 1988

It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back is built from dozens of uncleared samples layered into something genuinely abrasive, and it is the most confrontational record on this list by thirty years. The Bomb Squad made density itself the argument.

2
3 Feet High and Rising
2. The playfulness 3 Feet High and Rising De La Soul · 1989

3 Feet High and Rising answered Public Enemy with jokes, skits and a Hall & Oates sample, and proved the form could be light without being slight. Prince Paul's production is a collage of whatever was in the crate.

3
The Low End Theory
3. The cool The Low End Theory A Tribe Called Quest · 1991

The Low End Theory strips everything back to upright bass and drums — Ron Carter, who played on half the jazz canon, is on it. Q-Tip and Phife trade verses conversationally rather than competitively, and it is the easiest record here to simply put on.

4
Illmatic
4. The apex Illmatic Nas · 1994

Illmatic is ten tracks, thirty-nine minutes, and the usual answer to what the best rap album is. Nas was twenty and writing about one housing project in Queens with the precision of a novelist. The one to play if you want to understand why people make the claim.

5
Madvillainy
5. The abstraction Madvillainy Madvillain · 2004

Madvillainy is what happens when the form stops caring about radio entirely: no choruses, tracks that end mid-thought, MF DOOM rhyming in dense internal patterns over Madlib's murky loops. The exit toward everything underground that followed.