Guilty: 30 Years of Randy Newman cover

Guilty: 30 Years of Randy Newman

Randy Newman · 1998

303 min · 105 tracks · blues

A vibrant tapestry of orchestral pop, biting satire, and poignant storytelling that captures the essence of Americana.

Top tracks — play these first

  • →
    Love Story (You and Me) Start here — establishes the sonic palette early
  • →
    I Think It’s Going to Rain Today — This track exemplifies Newman's ability to blend melancholy themes with lush melodies, making it a standout representation of his poignant songwriting style.
  • →
    Sail Away — The song's ironic take on American ideals wrapped in a beautiful melody showcases Newman's trademark wit and social commentary.
  • →
    You’ve Got a Friend in Me — As one of his most recognizable songs, this track highlights Newman's knack for crafting relatable lyrics that resonate with audiences across all ages.
  • →
    Political Science — Newman's sharp satirical edge shines through in this song, critiquing American foreign policy with a catchy tune that emphasizes the absurdity of its themes.

Elevation

Our rating, out of 100 — and why.

AI-generated from five scored dimensions. An opinion, not a measurement.

71 /100
Treeline
Higher than 52% of albums we've rated

This compilation showcases Newman's diverse songwriting and production quality but lacks the tight cohesion of a studio album.

What we noticed

  • The album features a wide range of styles, with tracks that shift from orchestral arrangements to stripped-down piano ballads.
  • Many songs include satirical lyrics that critique American culture, often delivered with a conversational vocal style.
  • The sequencing includes both well-known hits and deeper cuts, creating a narrative arc that reflects Newman's career evolution.
Composition 25% of the score
7/10

the writing — melody, harmony, structure, lyrics

Craft 20% of the score
8/10

production, performance, arrangement

Durability 25% of the score
6/10

whether it rewards returning to it

Distinctiveness 18% of the score
7/10

whether it sounds like itself

Sequencing 12% of the score
5/10

running order, pacing, length

Influence 6/10

Significant within its genre. Reported but not counted — how far a record travelled describes its reception rather than the record, and a newer release has had less time to travel than an older one.

Is this for you?

Good fit if you like

  • quirky storytelling with sardonic wit
  • varied pacing for attentive listening
  • moments of poignant reflection
  • for nostalgic afternoon
  • great for sing-alongs with friends

Maybe skip if you

  • prefer high-energy instant gratification
  • avoid lengthy exploratory albums

Where this album fits

In the catalog
Deep Cut — A compilation that showcases Newman's career without being a primary entry point.
Themes
American satire· cultural critique
Career context
By the time 'Guilty: 30 Years of Randy Newman' was released in 1998, Randy Newman had established himself as a formidable songwriter and composer. This compilation marked his retrospective celebration of three decades in music, following his critical acclaim during the 1970s and 80s with hits like 'Short People' and his work on various film scores.
Stylistic neighbors
Harry Nilsson· Leonard Cohen· Tom Waits

Tracklist

Disc 1

  • 1 Love Story (You and Me) Start here 3:21
  • 2 Bet No One Ever Hurt This Bad 2:04
  • 3 Cowboy 2:38
  • 4 The Beehive State 1:50
  • 5 I Think It’s Going to Rain Today 2:58
  • 6 Davy the Fat Boy 2:48
  • 7 Have You Seen My Baby 2:32
  • 8 Let’s Burn Down the Cornfield 3:02
  • 9 Mama Told Me Not to Come 2:11
  • 10 Suzanne 3:09
  • 11 Old Kentucky Home 2:37
  • 12 Sail Away 2:52
  • 13 Lonely at the Top 2:32
  • 14 Last Night I Had a Dream 3:01
  • 15 Political Science 2:00
  • 16 Burn On 2:34
  • 17 Memo to My Son 1:53
  • 18 You Can Leave Your Hat On 3:14
  • 19 God’s Song (That’s Why I Love Mankind) 3:38
  • 20 Rednecks 3:09
  • 21 Birmingham 2:46
  • 22 Marie 3:09
  • 23 Guilty 2:32
  • 24 Louisiana 1927 2:56
  • 25 Kingfish 2:44
  • 26 Baltimore 4:03
  • 27 Rider in the Rain 3:53

Disc 2

  • 1 Short People 2:55
  • 2 Little Criminals 3:03
  • 3 In Germany Before the War 3:39
  • 4 I’ll Be Home 2:47
  • 5 It’s Money That I Love 3:40
  • 6 Ghosts 2:28
  • 7 The Girls in My Life (Part I) 2:37
  • 8 William Brown 1:50
  • 9 I Love L.A. 3:30
  • 10 Mikey’s 2:10
  • 11 My Life Is Good 4:38
  • 12 Miami 4:02
  • 13 Real Emotional Girl 2:29
  • 14 Take Me Back 4:09
  • 15 Song for the Dead 3:00
  • 16 Dixie Flyer 4:07
  • 17 New Orleans Wins the War 3:29
  • 18 Four Eyes 3:36
  • 19 It’s Money That Matters 4:03
  • 20 I Want You to Hurt Like I Do 4:06
  • 21 Can’t Keep a Good Man Down 2:43
  • 22 Bleeding All Over the Place (Alt. mix) 4:15
  • 23 Happy Ending 3:18

Disc 3

  • 1 Golden Gridiron Boy 1:56
  • 2 Vine Street 2:21
  • 3 Love Is Blind 1:36
  • 4 Don’t Ruin Our Happy Home 2:31
  • 5 The Goat 1:48
  • 6 Gone Dead Train 2:54
  • 7 Tickle Me 2:00
  • 8 Maybe I’m Doing It Wrong 1:25
  • 9 Yellow Man 2:13
  • 10 Magic in the Moon Light 1:48
  • 11 Beat Me Baby 1:58
  • 12 Simon Smith and the Amazing Dancing Bear 2:03
  • 13 Let Me Go 2:50
  • 14 Jesus in the Summertime 3:32
  • 15 Going Home 1:57
  • 16 Interiors 1:51
  • 17 Pretty Boy 4:01
  • 18 Something to Sing About 3:06
  • 19 The Ballad of the Three Amigos 2:16
  • 20 My Little Buttercup 2:05
  • 21 Blue Shadows on the Trail 2:47
  • 22 Happy 0:39
  • 23 The Longest Night 2:34
  • 24 Days of Heaven 2:25
  • 25 What Have You Done to Me 2:00
  • 26 Masterman and Baby J 1:52
  • 27 Lines in the Sand 2:31
  • 28 Gainsville 3:26
  • 29 Feels Like Home 4:12
  • 30 My Name Is James 2:43
  • 31 Laugh and Be Happy 2:13

Disc 4

  • 1 Rev Running 2:15
  • 2 Change Your Way 2:02
  • 3 Clef Club No. 1 1:43
  • 4 Clef Club No. 2 1:20
  • 5 Ragtime 2:45
  • 6 Prologue 1915–1923 5:21
  • 7 The Natural 3:35
  • 8 Introduction / I Love to See You Smile 3:25
  • 9 Kevin’s Party (Cowboy Gil) 3:23
  • 10 1914 3:40
  • 11 End Titles 7:19
  • 12 Leonard 4:30
  • 13 Dexter’s Tune 2:38
  • 14 Clocks 3:09
  • 15 Make Up Your Mind 3:14
  • 16 Opening 5:34
  • 17 Tartine de Merde 1:33
  • 18 You’ve Got a Friend in Me 2:04
  • 19 Woody and Buzz 4:30
  • 20 I Will Go Sailing No More 2:56
  • 21 Heaven Is My Home 3:05
  • 22 Main Title 0:36
  • 23 Clouds 1:40
  • 24 Good News 4:16

Reference: Wikipedia · MusicBrainz · Wikidata